The 2025-26 roster included nine players who donned teal for the first time. Joshua Beadle, AJ Dancler, Reggie Hill, and Nadjrick Peat all had a significant impact from the start and were major contributors to the Chanticleers' success.
- Beadle was a first-team all-conference selection and was voted Sun Belt Newcomer of the Year. He led Coastal in scoring with 17.5 points per game, scoring double figures in 26 games with 13 20-point performances and a pair of 30-point games.
- Dancler was the Chanticleers' best outside shooter, connecting on 39.0 percent of his 3-point attempts, while averaging 2.5 made 3s per game. He led the team with 79 made 3s, making six in a game three times. Dancler posted three 30-point performances.
- Hill started the final 30 games of the season and averaged a team-high 5.8 rebounds per game. He ranked fourth on the team in points per game, 3-point percentage and steals.
- Peat became the fourth player in program history to collect over 50 blocks in a season, finishing with 54. In his final home game, Peat set the school record for most blocked shots with seven against Marshall, nearly recording the first triple-double in school history. He ranked third in the SBC in total blocks and blocked shots per game (1.7).
Additional newcomers such DaJohn Craig, Derrick Green, Jerry Ngopot, and Tristan Thompson provided valuable minutes and versatility as the Chanticleers continued to develop throughout the season.